Cover art for “The Case of the Marenna”, a Istanbul Confidential radio drama

Istanbul Confidential29 minAI-made

The Case of the Marenna

After a rust hulk crowded with emigrant families sinks off Eskiova in the night, what is the Karaköy quay waiting to learn, and whose name will its grief demand?

Setting Istanbul, November 1941 — with Eskiova, Karaköy, Balat and Kestane.

Watch or listen

Watch on YouTube

Listen in the podcast player

Also on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, Pocket Casts, Deezer, Player FM, or add the RSS feed to any podcast app.

About this story

Read the story and the full transcript: https://matezz.com/episodes/the-case-of-the-marenna-istanbul-confidential/

In the second week of November 1941, a telephone rings in the rooms above the arcade. Inspector Tevfik, the port liaison of the Emniyet, reports that a rust hulk carrying emigrant families has gone down off Eskiova overnight. Those who reached shore are camped on the Karaköy quay among their luggage, while more than two hundred people are still in the water. Tevfik wants Kemal Arslan to listen to them before grief turns ugly, because quays run short on patience and long on rumour. Arslan and his friend Captain Haluk go down to the water.

They find that the ship's manifests went down with her, so no widow can prove she is one. By a brazier they meet Rahel, a saddler's widow from Balat, who paid for her husband's berth with the shop's winter takings and presses his photograph into the detective's hand. That evening a fisherman named Yorgo climbs the stairs with a drowned man's coat from his nets. Sewn into the lining are two steamship tickets, and in the buttoned pocket is a berth ticket marked with a ship's name, the Marenna, and the number 327.

Whose berth was it, and what does the harbour office know about the vessel that carried it?

#MonoNoirRadioDrama #NoirMystery #AudioDrama

Voices Narrator, Arslan, Tevfik, Rahel, Yorgo, Bension, Kolev

From the series Istanbul Confidential: a real wartime Istanbul case reimagined as a classic espionage noir radio mystery, performed by a full multi-voice AI cast with an original score and sound design.

Directed Edition — every role cast for this story and every line performed with full voice direction.

Chapters

  1. 0:00 A Cold Telephone Above the Arcade
  2. 1:43 Camped Among the Luggage
  3. 3:48 A Fisherman at the Door
  4. 5:33 Rain on the Harbour Office
  5. 7:20 Leather Dust in Balat
  6. 8:59 Dusk Over the Saddler's Street
  7. 10:35 Morning and a Restless Inspector
  8. 12:20 Noon by the Harbour Stove
  9. 15:02 Night Tea Above the Arcade
  10. 16:50 Morning at the Scarred Desk
  11. 18:23 Afternoon at the Saddler's Bench
  12. 20:12 The Lamp Burns Late
  13. 21:52 An Hour Before Dawn
  14. 24:17 A Door Pushed Open
  15. 25:12 Lamps Going Out Below
  16. 26:39 First Light on the Quay

Full transcript of “The Case of the Marenna”

Read along, search for a line, or listen with the sound off. Warning: the transcript contains the whole story, including the solution.

Read the full transcript (spoilers)

This is the whole story, solution included. Names mark who is speaking. Click a time to jump to that moment on YouTube. Stage directions are left out.

0:00 A Cold Telephone Above the Arcade

0:04 Narrator: Istanbul, the second week of November, nineteen forty-one. Rooms above the arcade, morning; Arslan and I, and the telephone ringing in the cold.

0:20 Arslan: Arslan. Tevfik: Tevfik, Emniyet, port liaison. Forgive the early hour, beyim.

0:26 Arslan: The hour's fine. The news rarely is, at this hour. Tevfik: A rust hulk went down off Eskiova in the night. Emigrant families. The ones who came ashore are camping on the Karaköy quay.

0:38 Arslan: How many came ashore? Tevfik: A hundred and twenty-odd, we count. Two hundred and more still in the water.

0:45 Arslan: And you want me to sit with them. Tevfik: I want you to listen before grief turns ugly. Quays are short on patience and long on rumour.

0:54 Arslan: And it'll want a name. Whose? Tevfik: Whoever the crowd decides. That's the trouble. Come before noon, beyim.

1:05 Narrator: He's right about the quay. I've seen a crowd decide a man's guilt between two calls to prayer. Arslan: Then we go before they decide.

1:13 Narrator: You'll take the file on the Eskiova traffic? Arslan: No file. Eyes and ears first. The dead don't talk; the living are in too much of a hurry.

1:23 Narrator: I'll fetch the coats. The samovar can cool; it's had worse mornings. Arslan: Captain — one thing. When we get there, let me do the asking.

1:33 Narrator: You always do the asking. I do the watching. Arslan: And I do the concluding. Which is why you fetch the coats.

1:43 Camped Among the Luggage

1:47 Narrator: Karaköy quay, before noon. Arslan and I, with the port inspector — and the families camped among their luggage. Tevfik: Mind the ropes. Half the Bursa third class sleeps under them still.

1:59 Arslan: They sleep on stone the same week they lost the— Tevfik: They lost more than the ship, bey. The manifests went down with it. No names, no berths, no proof of who boarded.

2:09 Narrator: So a widow can't even prove she's a widow. Tevfik: The consul asks for papers nobody can show. It's ugly, and it's mine.

2:19 Arslan: Who bought the passages? Someone here paid for a whole family. Tevfik: The saddler's widow, from Balat. She paid for the family's berths. She's by the brazier.

2:30 Rahel: You're the detective the inspector promised. Sit. The coals are for sharing.

2:35 Narrator: Madame, we're sorry for your loss. Rahel: Sorry. Yes. My husband worked leather forty years, and now I— now I count his customers instead of his children.

2:48 Arslan: You bought the passages yourself? Rahel: Every berth, with the shop's winter takings. He argued the fare down twice and still I paid too much.

2:58 Arslan: And he sailed anyway. Rahel: He sailed. And I can't— I lie awake doing the sums.

3:05 Narrator: Was he alone aboard? Rahel: With his tools and his good coat. A man travels with his hands, my mother said. His hands are at the bottom now.

3:16 Arslan: Madame. If I'm to sit with your family, I should know his face. Rahel: Then hold this. He was vain about that collar. Photographs outlast manifests, they tell me.

3:28 Arslan: He has your brow. Where does the family keep its shop? Rahel: In Balat. The saddler's lane, past the fountain, the door with the brass horseshoe. Come when the lamps are lit. I'll make coffee worth drinking.

3:42 Narrator: On the quay, the living queue for bread while the dead queue for papers.

3:48 A Fisherman at the Door

3:51 Narrator: Rooms above the arcade, evening. The lamp is lit, the coats are hung, and a fisherman stands dripping on the boards between us. Yorgo: Captain. Efendi. Forgive the smell, a night and a day hauling nets off Eskiova.

4:07 Narrator: The smell of an honest catch, Yorgo. Sit. There's coffee, if Arslan has left any.

4:13 Arslan: I left half the cezve. A man who nets coats deserves more than half. Yorgo: Coats. That's the thing. My nets brought up a man's coat, heavy as an anchor.

4:24 Arslan: Show me. And the pockets? Yorgo: Empty, you'd think. But see, the berth ticket came up with it, still buttoned in the pocket. I touched nothing else, I— I swear it on my boat.

4:37 Narrator: You swear well. A man who wanted silver would have torn the lining. Yorgo: Silver? There was nothing but thread and salt. Why would a drowned man carry a ticket and no lira?

4:49 Arslan: Because a ticket is worth more than lira. It says where he was going. Yorgo: Huh.

4:56 Narrator: That collar, Kemal — the one in the widow's photograph. Read it, and let the paper finish the sentence. Arslan: Sewn into the lining — two steamship tickets, third class. And this, loose, in the buttoned pocket.

5:11 Yorgo: A berth ticket? He had a berth and still— Arslan: Went down, yes. Every number has a name behind it. Demir, the manifest office keeps hours till nine.

5:21 Narrator: Then we have an hour. Read the port, Kemal. The names can wait for the clerk.

5:25 Arslan: The ticket reads: Marenna. Berth three hundred and twenty-seven.

5:33 Rain on the Harbour Office

5:36 Narrator: Harbour office at Karaköy, the hour after dawn, rain on the window — Arslan and I, and Inspector Tevfik with a registry open between us. Tevfik: You came by the ticket. Good. Because the file answers it before I do.

5:51 Arslan: Does it? Tevfik: Marenna. Read it yourself if you doubt my—

5:56 Arslan: I doubt everything before breakfast. Read. Tevfik: Vessel Marenna, formerly Ottoman registry. Sold at Kestane in October. Re-papered under the Uruguayan flag — Montevideo papers, new owner, new colours.

6:10 Narrator: Montevideo. That's a long way from the Marmara. Tevfik: Far enough that her papers were clean. And here's the thing: a foreign hull in our waters, no port could stop her.

6:22 Arslan: Not board her? Not even for— Tevfik: Not board, not hold, not question. Istanbul, Haydarpaşa, Karaova. Every harbour on our sea watched her steam past and couldn't lift a finger.

6:36 Narrator: So whoever bought her at Kestane bought her a passport. Tevfik: Bought her the one flag nobody in the Marmara could touch. Neat, is it not?

6:46 Arslan: Very neat. Who was the buyer? Tevfik: A name on paper. Some Uruguayan concern that exists, I suspect, in one inkwell and nowhere else.

6:57 Narrator: And berth three hundred and twenty-seven? Tevfik: Sold twice, Captain. Once to the families, once to the sea.

7:05 Tevfik: That's the whole file. The flag kept every port out, and the— well. The bottom of the sea kept every passenger in.

7:14 Arslan: Then we stop chasing harbours. We chase the inkwell.

7:20 Leather Dust in Balat

7:23 Narrator: A saddler's shop in Balat, the afternoon light thick with leather dust. Bension has crossed the Black Sea to stand at Rahel's bench, and Arslan and I stand between them. Bension: This is my receipt. Kestane broker, red wax, his mark pressed crooked.

7:41 Rahel: And this is my ticket. Bought here, in Balat, from a man with the same red stamp on his scale. Arslan: May I lay them side by side?

7:50 Bension: Look at the numbers. Two berths. The same two berths.

7:55 Rahel: Three twenty-six and three twenty-seven. I bought them for my husband and my sister's boy. Bension: Three twenty-seven was my daughter's. She sailed on it.

8:06 Rahel: Oh... oh, no. Narrator: You sold your shop for those berths? Bension: Everything. The awl, the last hides, the lot. And then a man in Karaköy offered me the same berths again — no, that's not it. He never offered. He just took the money.

8:22 Arslan: Who took it? Bension: A broker with a red stamp and a soft voice. Same stamp as Kestane. The same— I swear it on my daughter's head.

8:32 Rahel: The same stamp. I'd know that crooked wax anywhere. Bension: My daughter's berth was sold twice, same red stamp. She sailed believing it was hers alone...

8:45 Narrator: One ship. One broker's stamp. Two families paid for the same planks.

8:51 Arslan: And the broker kept one copy of each receipt. Somewhere there is a ledger with both names in it.

8:59 Dusk Over the Saddler's Street

9:03 Narrator: Dusk finds Balat's saddler street shuttered, and inside the shop Arslan, Tevfik, Rahel, Bension and I wait on one more — the passage-broker from Kestane. Kolev: Good evening. Kolev, passage-broker, Kestane. Rebookings, new sailings, fair terms.

9:21 Rahel: My brother's receipt and my ticket carry your red stamp, mister. Two berths, sold twice. Kolev: Madame, the weather's not my doing. New berths, half the old money back.

9:33 Arslan: And the other half went where? Kolev: Costs, sir. A broker eats too.

9:39 Tevfik: Before terms, Kolev bey — a question of bookkeeping. The wreck inquiry, read aloud: the Marenna's passenger book went down with her. No paper ever printed the count.

9:50 Kolev: A drowned ledger, inspector. God keeps that arithmetic now. Arslan: Then how many berths did you sell for that—

9:57 Kolev: The number escapes me. Kestane is a busy office. Rahel: My husband drowned believing his name was written somewhere.

10:05 Kolev: I don't deal in what people believe, madame. New sailings leave Thursday. Shall I pencil you both—

10:11 Narrator: You pencil fast, for a man who can't recall a figure. Kolev: Pencil can be rubbed out. Good night to the house.

10:19 Arslan: Haluk. A question to carry home. Who sells berths on a drowned ship?

10:25 Narrator: A man who never expected the ship to sail at all. Arslan: Exactly. The count never mattered — until it does.

10:35 Morning and a Restless Inspector

10:38 Narrator: Rooms above the arcade, nine in the morning. The samovar is back on the boil, and Inspector Tevfik has climbed the stairs with his theory under his arm. Tevfik: Captain. Mr. Arslan. I've been awake since four with— with one thought.

10:52 Arslan: The good ones keep you up. Tell it. Tevfik: Your fisherman. Yorgo. He nets a coat off a drowned man, and inside the lining — tickets, sewn in like money.

11:04 Narrator: Sewn, yes. With a berth ticket still buttoned in the pocket. Tevfik: Yes, yes. A poor man finds gold on the water. He robs the dead and stitches it where nobody pats him down. Oldest crime on the Bosphorus.

11:19 Arslan: Is it? A robber who sews instead of spends? Tevfik: He waits for the fuss to die. Then he sells the find quietly, ticket by—

11:28 Arslan: And walks it up my stairs first? Why bring the coat to us at all, Inspector? Tevfik: Fear. The port is crawling with your questions.

11:36 Narrator: Or the man can't sew a straight seam and wanted advice. Tevfik: You two defend him like a relative. Arslan: I'm defending the sums. A drowned ship, a drowned book, and one fisherman who happens to hook the one coat that matters.

11:52 Tevfik: Coin happens, Arslan. Arslan: Twice in one week? Same water, same net? I'd like to hear him squeezed properly. Noon, somewhere with a table between him and the sea.

12:04 Tevfik: Then hear this: I'll have him brought to the harbour office at noon. My room, my questions, you two watching. Narrator: And if he cries?

12:13 Tevfik: Fishermen cry salt, Captain. It won't move me. Arslan: We'll see.

12:20 Noon by the Harbour Stove

12:23 Narrator: Karaköy's harbour office, noon — the stove ticking, Tevfik behind his desk, Arslan and I by the chart, Yorgo dripping on the boards. Tevfik: Sit down, fisherman. Let's not waste each other's daylight.

12:37 Yorgo: I stood in your rain since dawn. Since dawn, inspector. Ask what you came to ask.

12:45 Tevfik: A dead man's coat. You netted it, you kept it a night, and by morning it's full of paper worth a passage. Who taught a Eskiova fisherman to—

12:53 Yorgo: Sew? I— I mend nets. Nothing more.

12:57 Tevfik: Then where did the stitching come from? Arslan: From the maker, Inspector. Ask instead what was already there when Yorgo pulled the coat aboard.

13:06 Tevfik: Which was? Arslan: The berth ticket. The dead man carried it where a careful man carries paper — inside the coat, fastened shut. The button was done up over it. Still buttoned in the pocket.

13:20 Yorgo: That's the truth of it. I found the coat heavy, opened it on my knee, and there it sat, sewn in the lining, buttoned in the pocket. I touched nothing else.

13:31 Tevfik: Convenient. A coat that travels with its fortune sewn— Arslan: No, Inspector. A man who trusted no ship's hold. He carried his paper on his body because he'd been sold once before.

13:43 Tevfik: Sold? Arslan: Ask Kestane. Ask the red stamp. The same berth, sold twice — the dead man knew what a ticket in a trunk was worth.

13:53 Tevfik: That is not in my file. Arslan: Your file has the flag. The flag kept every port out. It says nothing about berths sold twice over a table in Balat.

14:04 Narrator: Kemal — gently. The man drowned believing his paper was good. Arslan: I'm not blaming the dead man, Captain. I'm getting the fisherman off the hook.

14:14 Tevfik: Then the fisherman walks. Yorgo: I walk. But hear me, inspector — my brothers pulled that water for two days for your dead. They'll not drag again for an accusation.

14:27 Tevfik: Yorgo — Yorgo: No. The sea gave up what it had. Emniyet got its coat and its paper and called the finder a thief. Let your constables swim.

14:36 Narrator: There goes the quay's goodwill, out with him. Arslan: Worse than goodwill, Captain. Those men trusted us. That won't mend quick.

14:45 Tevfik: I had a thief yesterday. What have I got now? Arslan: A drowned man who carried his ticket buttoned where no wave could take it — and someone ashore who sold him a berth twice and is still counting the money.

14:59 Tevfik: Lord...

15:02 Night Tea Above the Arcade

15:05 Narrator: Rooms above the arcade again, the samovar breathing steam into the November dark — two men, two facts, and no conclusion between them. Two chairs, one samovar, and a night with nothing to do but think. Arslan: Thinking is the work tonight. Pour.

15:24 Narrator: Fact one. The flag. No harbour could touch her — Tevfik's own file said so.

15:30 Arslan: No port could stop her. She anchored off Eskiova, and the boats came out to her. Narrator: Of course. And fact two sits heavier. One red stamp, sold twice. Bension's receipt and Rahel's ticket — twins.

15:47 Arslan: Twins. Yet only one of those berths ever existed. Narrator: You're saying the count was never real.

15:55 Arslan: No paper ever printed the count. A book that sinks takes every lie with it. Narrator: So Kolev could sell the same water twice and—

16:04 Arslan: I said no conclusion. Two facts on the table, that's all. Not a rope.

16:09 Narrator: Forgive me. The samovar makes me bold. Arslan: Quick, more like. Not the same thing.

16:16 Narrator: Then let me be slow. What do we wire Kestane tonight? Arslan: Whether the agent who stamped those berths ever held a ship at all.

16:26 Narrator: Ah. And if the answer comes back empty? Arslan: Then somebody on that quay did this. And it wasn't the sea.

16:36 Narrator: When do we hear? Arslan: Dawn. The wire travels by night and arrives with the milk carts.

16:43 Narrator: Then we drink tea until the city wakes. Arslan: Slowly, then. Morning'll bring hurry enough.

16:50 Morning at the Scarred Desk

16:54 Narrator: Karaköy's harbour office, morning, the day after the wire went out — Arslan, Inspector Tevfik and I around a scarred desk. Tevfik: Kestane answered. The broker's own tally, gentlemen, copied word for word.

17:08 Arslan: Read it, or shall I? Tevfik: You. My Ankara accent mangles his ledger hand.

17:15 Arslan: "Fares sold by Kolev, broker: three hundred and twenty-seven. Gold received in full. Last berth taken the third of November. Signed, the Kestane office."

17:28 Narrator: Three hundred and twenty-seven. The same number stitched to Rahel's husband's coat. Arslan: The broker counted every fare he sold. He kept the gold and the count together.

17:41 Tevfik: So the book that sank... there wasn't a book. There never was any book. Arslan: Precisely. He sold from a slip of paper in his pocket. The sea took the ship, not his arithmetic.

17:55 Narrator: Clever devil. Then the families can ask him for the figure itself. He knows what each of them—

18:02 Tevfik: Paid, yes. They can ask. Whether he answers is another morning's work.

18:08 Arslan: One thing is certain. Kolev has never heard this number read aloud. Until now, it belonged to Kestane.

18:15 Narrator: And to whoever wired it. Tevfik: Which means the count's ours, gentlemen. We show it to him, and we watch his face.

18:23 Afternoon at the Saddler's Bench

18:27 Narrator: The saddler's shop in Balat, mid-afternoon: Arslan and I, the Kestane broker Kolev, and Rahel bent over her bench. Kolev: Madam, those new berths I offer — keep them. Safe passage, guaranteed.

18:41 Rahel: Guaranteed. My husband's berth was guaranteed too. Kolev: The sea is the sea. I sell what floats.

18:49 Arslan: You sell what already sank, Mr. Kolev. Coffee? Kolev: Black, thank you. You're generous with it.

18:57 Rahel: I bought twice. Same red stamp. And now a third time? Why would I—

19:02 Kolev: Because this time the berths are real. The old book is— it's gone. No paper ever printed the count, so nobody can say what was owed.

19:11 Arslan: Nobody living, you mean. Kolev: No man living can number the drowned. The sea keeps its own books.

19:18 Rahel: Then how do you know what to refund? You offered me money. This morning, you offered me money.

19:25 Kolev: A broker's conscience. Rough figures. Kindness.

19:29 Arslan: Is that so. Kolev: Look, look. The new berths follow on, since the old book stopped at three hundred and twenty-seven. After that, nothing. So we start clean.

19:41 Rahel: Stopped? A book doesn't stop. It sinks. You said so yourself, at dusk.

19:49 Kolev: Sunk, stopped, it's— drowned men don't quibble. Arslan: You just did. Where did you learn the number?

19:57 Kolev: Quay talk. Kestane's full of it. Arslan: Quay talk about a book that's at the bottom of the—

20:03 Kolev: Talk gets everywhere, Effendi. That's all I know. Rahel: He counted them. He counted my husband...

20:12 The Lamp Burns Late

20:16 Narrator: The rooms above the arcade, well past supper, and only the two of us left with the lamp. The wire's copy lies between us like a card nobody will turn. Arslan: He'll come at ten?

20:27 Narrator: To the saddler's. Bension opens early; Rahel will be grinding ink by nine. Arslan: Then the note must say nothing but the hour and the place. Narrator: And nothing of the question?

20:39 Arslan: Nothing. If he knows what's coming, he knows what to carry out of the room. Narrator: You're sure the number is the lever?

20:47 Arslan: I'm sure only he flinched when the tally stopped. Rahel grieves. Bension trades. Kolev... Kolev counts.

20:57 Narrator: Counts, does he. Arslan: Down to the coin. Tomorrow we find out how far.

21:03 Narrator: Wax is soft. Say the word and I'll seal it with the arcade stamp. Arslan: Seal it. Then wake the boy who runs the night errands. The small one, with the lantern.

21:14 Narrator: Down the stairs, along the deserted arcade, past the coffee-house embers. Arslan: Tell him ten o'clock, and no stopping at the quay to gossip. Narrator: He'll want paying.

21:26 Arslan: Give him a lira and keep the change. Cheap, for a man's whole ledger. Narrator: Generous.

21:33 Narrator: Gone. The lantern's already at the corner. Arslan: Then tomorrow, Balat, ten o'clock. We ask one question, and watch whose hands move.

21:43 Narrator: And if nobody flinches? Arslan: Somebody always flinches. The trick is standing close enough to see it.

21:52 An Hour Before Dawn

21:56 Narrator: Rooms above the arcade, an hour before dawn. Two men, one lamp, a samovar gone cold. I have heard many confessions, but none stranger than a number repeating itself.

22:09 Arslan: Say it back to me, Haluk. The first one. Narrator: You've had me saying it since midnight. No man living can number the drowned.

22:19 Arslan: And the second. The one he dropped at the door. Narrator: Stopped at three hundred and twenty-seven.

22:27 Arslan: There. Did you hear it? Narrator: I heard a man quoting the quay. Half of Balat could have told him—

22:33 Arslan: Told him what? He swore the book sank with her, and still knew to the berth where it stopped. Only the man who kept it knows that.

22:42 Narrator: You think he kept the count all along. Arslan: I know he did. But that's fraud, Haluk. Petty, proveable. Why does it keep me awake?

22:52 Narrator: Because a man who counts the drowned... Arslan: Finish it. Narrator: Because a man who counts the drowned is a man who was there when they went down. Or made them go down.

23:05 Arslan: Closer. Say the two sentences together. Once more.

23:10 Narrator: No man alive could count the drowned. And yet he stopped at three hundred and twenty-seven. Arslan: Hear yourself?

23:19 Narrator: I hear... God. I hear it.

23:23 Arslan: A number is a count. A count needs a counter. He swears nobody living can do it.

23:30 Narrator: Then either he's lying about the count— Arslan: Or lying about the living. Narrator: You're saying he never cared whether she arrived. He sold the berths and let the sea keep his books.

23:42 Arslan: I'm saying a man who knows a number no living man can count learned it from the only place such numbers are kept. Narrator: The drowned keep no books, Kemal. Arslan: No. But the man who drowned them keeps excellent ones.

23:59 Narrator: Ten o'clock, Balat. He'll swear it's quay talk again. Arslan: Quay talk doesn't count to the last gold lira. Tomorrow we ask him where he got it.

24:09 Narrator: And if he won't say? Arslan: Then we say it for him. Slowly. In front of the families.

24:17 A Door Pushed Open

24:21 Narrator: Balat, the saddler's shop, ten o'clock. Arslan, Tevfik, Rahel, Bension and I wait — and the passage-broker Kolev pushes through the door. Kolev: Good morning, all. I've come about the berths, that's all. Rahel, your new passage is safe. Sign, and we're—

24:38 Rahel: Safe on what ship, Kolev? The one that floats, this time? Arslan: One question first, Mr. Kolev. Yesterday you swore no man living could count the drowned. Then your book stopped at three hundred and twenty-seven. Who counted?

24:54 Kolev: Quay talk, Effendi. I— everyone knows— Tevfik: Kestane wired us your own tally, Kolev bey. Three hundred and twenty-seven, gold received in full. Open that case.

25:06 Tevfik: Red-stamped receipts, and liras. You're under arrest for fraud.

25:12 Lamps Going Out Below

25:16 Narrator: Rooms above the arcade, the same evening, and three men bent over a seized case while the lamps below go out one by one. Tevfik: Here's her whole paper life. Registry first — sold at Kestane, reflagged out of Montevideo. Under that flag, no port could stop her.

25:34 Arslan: So she steamed our sea wearing another country's coat. Tevfik: Exactly. Every harbourmaster we have could only watch her pass.

25:44 Narrator: And the receipts? Tevfik: Red-stamped, all of them. Look at the dates against the quay tally.

25:50 Arslan: They run past the sunken count. Three hundred and forty fares sold in all. Tevfik: Heaven help them.

25:58 Narrator: Thirteen berths beyond the drowned. Tevfik: Thirteen families who paid for berths that were never there. Arslan: The second fares, weighed. That stack is heavy for paper.

26:11 Tevfik: Gold liras, counted on my own cabinet. Kolev took coin, not receipts. Narrator: He sold the same berths twice and charged twice.

26:21 Arslan: And the first fares he never refunded. Tevfik: Which is why this last stack comes with me tonight. Narrator: Where to, Inspector?

26:29 Tevfik: Back to the quay at dawn. The families will see it weighed in the open. Arslan: They've waited long enough for an honest scale.

26:39 First Light on the Quay

26:42 Narrator: Karaköy quay, first light, and the gulls already at the fish crates. I stood with Arslan, Tevfik, Bension and Rahel between the bollards, the last of the vigil. Tevfik: Two crates, gentlemen. Counted, sealed, witnessed.

26:57 Bension: Then open them. I'll know my own gold by the hand. Rahel: Slowly, brother. We've rushed enough for one voyage.

27:06 Tevfik: The tally stands. Kolev goes before the prosecutor at nine. Held for the Kestane boat, two counts of fraud and one of the gold.

27:14 Arslan: Two counts? Tevfik: Bension's berths. Rahel's berths. The gold he'll answer for separately.

27:21 Bension: And my daughter? Who answers for— Tevfik: The charge is paper, Bension. The court can't weigh... I'm sorry.

27:29 Rahel: Then weigh this. My husband's photograph comes home with me, and the money he saved to send us ahead. Arslan: Take what's yours, hanım. Leave the rest for the men with ledgers.

27:41 Narrator: The first fares are gone with the hull, then. Nothing on this quay brings them back. Bension: Gone. Gone for good. I've cursed the sea and I've cursed the broker, every day since Eskiova.

27:55 Arslan: And the second gold? Tevfik: Handed back, coin by coin, against his receipts. The red-stamped ones we keep as evidence.

28:03 Rahel: Then it's finished, captain? Narrator: The page turns. The file stays open till the court signs it, but for us — finished.

28:13 Tevfik: There's your morning boat. The city's waking whether we close the book or not. Bension: I sail for Kestane on her, God willing. To tell my wife... to tell her their daughter's berth was bought twice and paid for once.

28:27 Rahel: And I walk home to Balat with my husband's face in my pocket. Arslan: Go home, both of you. The quay owes you nothing now but quiet.

28:37 Narrator: Cold morning for a verdict, Kemal. Arslan: Warm enough. The scale tipped the right way before breakfast.

28:44 Narrator: Kolev answered for two forged berths and a crate of gold; for the two hundred and four the sea kept, no court ever called him. And Istanbul, as it always does, sent its ferries out over the same water.

  • Istanbul Confidential

    The Sick Uncle

    General Dorn, the German commander on Chios, vanished from the island four nights ago. The German consulate swears he was carried into Turkey, Ankara fears a pretext for war in Thrace, and the police director, writing in his own hand with no letterhead, asks the Istanbul detective Kemal Arslan to look into it quietly. Whatever became of the general, whom does his vanishing serve?

  • Istanbul Confidential

    No Envoy Came

    Selim Hoca, a schoolteacher whose society was banned, goes to a hall in Istanbul to meet an envoy from Ankara. He is shot at the curb outside. The tea is untouched, the hall's telephone line has been cut with pliers, and the police director wants a quick verdict. Who shot him?

  • Istanbul Confidential

    The Cuckoo's Hour

    A letter signed by men who call themselves the Brigade says an Istanbul hotel was telephoned a warning at ten past twelve, well before its wing came down. The switchboard operator who took the call swears it was half past. Which of them is right about the time?

  • Istanbul Confidential

    The Nickel War

    After a Sirkeci freight clerk is strangled and his death is filed as a robbery, why does his widow bring his hidden book to a detective instead of the police?